Avoid Common Pitfalls: Best Practices for Updating Your Employee Handbook

An employee handbook functions as a vital compliance document and internal governance tool. When structured properly, it promotes consistency, supports risk management, and provides employees with a clear understanding of company policies and expectations. In today’s ever-evolving legal landscape, maintaining a thoughtfully written and regularly updated employee handbook is crucial for employers.

Essential considerations for employers when preparing or updating an employee handbook include:

• Understanding the importance of a compliant handbook;
• Considering the legal implications of a handbook;
• Including essential policies;
• Tailoring the handbook to the organization;
• Avoiding common errors and pitfalls;
• Implementing and communicating handbook policies; and
• Ongoing maintenance.

A well-drafted employee handbook ensures that all company policies and practices are communicated clearly, thereby minimizing the risk of potential discrimination, disparate treatment, and other employment-related claims or lawsuits.

Employers should carefully consider their obligations and potential legal and business risks when creating and updating employee handbooks. This overview provides best practices for employers when drafting an employee handbook.

Best Practices for Drafting and Maintaining an Employee Handbook

The Importance of a Legally Compliant Handbook

A well-crafted employee handbook is more than a collection of workplace policies; it serves as a cornerstone of an organization’s legal compliance, a clear line of communication between the employer and its employees, and a powerful tool for reinforcing company culture. However, employers often underestimate the legal and cultural impact of employee handbooks. When properly developed, an employee handbook minimizes legal risk, promotes consistent policy enforcement, and gives employees a transparent view of the organization’s expectations. A well-constructed handbook can serve as a frontline defense during disputes, audits, and legal actions by helping employers establish good faith compliance with legal requirements.

Employee handbooks serve multiple functions, including:

• Communicating company values and workplace rules;
• Outlining an organization’s policies and procedures;
• Fostering clear communication;
• Clarifying employment practices;
• Answering common employee questions;
• Supporting legal compliance;
• Establishing performance and behavior expectations; and
• Protecting an employer in the event of a legal dispute.

Legal Considerations

Avoiding Contractually Binding Language

Most employee handbooks are meant to educate employees on an employer’s policies and expectations. They are not intended to create a contractual obligation between employees and the organization. However, employer missteps and careless language can establish unintended contractual relationships between an employer and its employees. Therefore, it’s important for employers to include disclaimers and avoid promises that could be interpreted as binding commitments. Disclaimers can help clarify the purpose of the handbook and define the terms of the employment relationship, thereby mitigating the risk of an employer being bound by the text of the employee handbook. For example, employers can include a disclaimer stating that the organization reserves the right to revise its policies at any time. To be effective, disclaimers should be prominently featured in the handbook and understandable to the average employee, and specific.

Additionally, employers should avoid language that suggests guarantees or entitlements. Clearly defining the terms of the employment relationship can also help mitigate the risk of an employer being contractually bound to the text of the employee handbook.

Employers should include a signed acknowledgment form to confirm an employee’s receipt and understanding of the handbook. Additionally, acknowledging specific policies, such as anti-discrimination, anti-harassment, and confidentiality policies, can further support compliance by helping organizations demonstrate that they have followed their workplace policies if personnel issues arise later.

Maintaining Employees’ At-Will Employment Status

Most employment relationships are at-will, which means that an employment relationship may be terminated at any time (with or without cause) and for any reason (or no reason) as long as it is lawful. However, an at-will employment relationship may be eliminated by an employment contract or applicable laws. Unless a unique employment relationship exists, employers should clearly state that the employee handbook does not overrule existing at-will employment relationships. Employers should also ensure that other policies do not undermine the at-will employment relationship, such as probationary periods, which may create the impression that employment is guaranteed for a specific period, or progressive discipline policies, which may fail to clearly state that an employee can be terminated at any time.

While an employee handbook is not a contractual agreement, careless language can create legal ambiguity. Employers should consider the following when preparing an employee handbook:

• Incorporating a clear at-will employment disclaimer;
• Avoiding language suggesting guarantees or entitlements; and
• Ensuring conformity with federal, state, and local employment laws.

Employers should also ask every employee to sign an acknowledgment that clearly states they recognize and agree that nothing contained in the handbook is intended to create a contractual relationship or alter the at-will nature of their employment.

Employers can include the following language in their employee handbook to further emphasize at-will employment relationships:

• Written or oral statements made to the employee are not to be interpreted as altering the at-will relationship;
• Disciplinary procedures in the handbook may be adjusted or modified at any time and at the employer’s discretion;
• The employer reserves the right to change any terms or conditions of employment, whether these are stated in the handbook or established through employment practices; and
• The terms and conditions contained in the employee handbook may only be altered in writing and signed by specified officers of the organization (e.g., owner, president, or chief executive officer).

Ensuring Compliance With Legal Requirements

Lastly, employers should ensure that the policies and procedures in their employee handbook comply with federal, state, and local laws to mitigate legal risk and ensure compliance with regulatory standards. An employee handbook may be presented as evidence in an employment law litigation. Therefore, employers should consider this when preparing and drafting employee handbooks and be prepared to defend the policies included therein.

A legally sound handbook ensures consistent treatment of employees and provides clear guidance in workplace decision-making, supporting both accountability and transparency. In contrast, non-compliant policies can expose an organization to costly litigation, fines, and reputational damage. Employers must also be vigilant about regularly reviewing and updating their employee handbooks. Areas of employment law that can change frequently include employee leave, wage and hour laws, and anti-discrimination regulations.

Some policies may not be legally required under federal, state, and local laws, but including them in an employee handbook can help establish employer expectations for its workforce and protect the organization from unlawful behavior and potential legal risk. Examples of these policies include performance reviews, social media guidelines, internal complaint procedures, and an employee code of conduct.

Essential Components of an Employee Handbook

While employee handbooks often vary by company size, industry, and geographic location of an employer’s workforce, a well-constructed employee handbook includes many sections and specific policies that are clear and accessible for all employees to reference. Determining which topics to include in an employee handbook can be a complex and challenging task. When deciding which policies to incorporate into a handbook, employers should consider the following commonly included policies:

• A welcome and purpose statement;
• A mission statement;
• An at-will employment statement;
• Employee code of ethics;
• Employment authorization and verification requirements;
• Equal employment opportunity and anti-harassment policies;
• Expectations around behavior, appearance, and workplace conduct;
• Pay practices, hours of wor,k and timekeeping practices;
• Confidential information and company property policies;
• Leave policies, including policies covering any required federal, state, or local leave entitlements;
• Safety procedures, including drug and alcohol testing and violence in the workplace policies, and emergency response plans;
• Guidelines on the use of technology, the internet, and social media;
• Employment benefits, such as employer-offered insurance and COBRA benefits policies; and
• Discipline, termination, and grievance procedures.

These policies should reflect not only the organization’s legal obligations but also its values and operational priorities.

Additionally, some laws and regulations require employers to have written policies on certain issues or topics. These requirements often vary by state or locality where employers operate. Employers should familiarize themselves with these requirements and ensure that their employee handbooks contain any required policies.

Tailoring the Employee Handbook to the Organization

Organizations should align their employee handbook with their company culture, values, and operational realities. A one-size-fits-all approach to an employee handbook rarely serves a business well. For example, an organization with remote or hybrid employees will likely need robust remote work and cybersecurity policies. At the same time, a manufacturer may prioritize OSHA compliance and safety training protocols in its handbook.

Since no single template applies universally to all organizations, employers must tailor their employee handbooks to reflect industry-specific obligations (e.g., HIPAA compliance for health care employers or OSHA standards for manufacturers), company structure, and evolving workplace norms, such as remote and hybrid work arrangements. Additionally, employers should consider adapting the tone, format, and organization of their employee handbook to the nature of the organization’s business and workforce. For most employers, using a standard format may be suitable. However, for others, choosing a different format, such as a frequently asked questions section, may be more appropriate.

Avoiding Common Handbook Errors and Pitfalls

Many common employee handbook issues or errors often stem from an employer’s oversight, including:

• Copying policies for other organizations;
• Relying on outdated templates;
• Failing to define important terms or expectations;
• Using inconsistent or vague language that confuses employees or contradicts legal regulations and requirements;
• Neglecting to collect signed acknowledgment forms from employees; and
• Allowing the handbook to become outdated.

Regular handbook audits can help avoid many of these common pitfalls.

Handbook language should be clear and unambiguous. However, employers sometimes draft policies in a way that is difficult for employees to understand, relying on legalese and other jargon. Organizations can avoid this by defaulting to clear and accessible everyday language that all employees can understand. If a significant number of employees do not understand English or if English is not their primary language, employers should consider translating their handbook into other languages so the entire workforce can understand it.

Another common issue is drafting policies in a manner that can be construed as infringing on employee rights. For example, in recent years, there has been increased scrutiny of unlawful restrictions in employment policies on employee rights under the National Labor Relations Act, specifically the right to engage in protected concerted activity or collective action to improve wages, hours, and working conditions. Failing to recognize key differences between federal, state, and local laws can often result in violations of employee rights. Therefore, employers should review their employee handbooks to ensure that policies do not infringe on employee rights or fail to distinguish between applicable laws.

Employees should be able to easily use and reference an employee handbook. Employers can do this by using a user-friendly format when designing handbooks. This often involves grouping similar policies and making them easy to find, enabling employees to quickly locate specific policies. Including a table of contents or index can also make it easier for employees to navigate and locate workplace policies.

Retaining qualified legal counsel to review an employee handbook is often one of the most effective ways to identify errors and address potential risks. Legal professionals can catch subtle compliance issues and ensure an organization’s policies align with current laws and regulations.

Implementing and Communicating Workplace Policies

Once the handbook is finalized, employers should focus on training and communicating workplace policies and any updates to employees. Organizations should train managers and employees on the policies outlined in their employee handbook, explaining how the employer will implement and use the handbook. This can help employees become familiar with the employee handbook and understand the employer’s workplace policies.

To ensure that workplace policies are communicated effectively to employees, organizations can determine the best way to distribute their employee handbook. For some workplaces, distributing an electronic version of the handbook may be the most effective approach. This has the added benefit of saving time and expense in printing and distributing the handbook. Additionally, many organizations distribute the employee handbook during onboarding or new hire orientation. This enables employees to become familiar with workplace policies and expectations from the outset of their employment, which can enhance employee engagement and retention. When distributing handbooks, employers should also require employees to acknowledge receipt, review, and consent to the employee handbook by signing and dating an acknowledgment form. Importantly, organizations should consider having an employment attorney review their handbook or any updates before making it available to employees.

Employers must ensure that employment policies are readily accessible to all employees, whether in print, digital format, or integrated into the organization’s onboarding platform. They must also document who has received them and when for record-keeping and compliance purposes. Employees should know where to find and how to access their organization’s employee handbook.

Ongoing Handbook Maintenance

An employee handbook is a living document that evolves with an organization as the law or business changes. Therefore, it’s essential for employers to review their employee handbook regularly to ensure that organizational standards comply with legal requirements. Regular review can also help employers eliminate any inaccuracies or inconsistencies in their policies. Employers should review and update their employee handbook annually, at a minimum. However, employers should monitor federal, state, and local legal developments and update their handbooks accordingly. If major legal changes occur, employers should consider updating their handbooks more frequently. When making changes or updates, it can be wise to seek feedback from leadership and employees to fine-tune policies and respond to evolving workplace dynamics.

When an employer revises its employee handbook, it should communicate any changes to all employees to avoid confusion and provide them with the updates. For significant changes, employers can require all employees to sign an additional acknowledgment form, which verifies that each employee understands and accepts the changes to the handbook. A revised employee handbook should indicate that it supersedes any prior versions. Employers should retain copies of old handbooks for the maximum statute of limitations period under applicable federal, state, and local laws.

Employer Takeaways

An up-to-date and clearly written employee handbook is an indispensable risk management and workforce communication tool for employers. However, if poorly drafted or left outdated, a handbook may expose an organization to liability. Therefore, organizations should invest the necessary time and legal expertise to ensure their employee handbooks comply with all applicable legal requirements and serve their intended purpose.

Whether an employer is drafting an employee handbook from scratch or revamping an existing one, by following the best practices outlined in this article, employers can better ensure that their employee handbook promotes consistency throughout the employment relationship, protects the organization, and meets the demands of today’s workplace. A comprehensive handbook, developed with proper legal oversight, can help mitigate risks and support an employer’s overall compliance efforts.

©2025 Zywave, Inc. All rights reserved.

Let GTM Provide an Updated, Compliant Employee Handbook

If handling all of the above seems daunting and you don’t have the time or resources to do it right, GTM can help.

GTM works with you to create an employee handbook that is compliant with state and federal laws. Our depth of knowledge in workplace policies and best practices ensures that the needs of both employees and employers are taken into account, providing you with peace of mind. Our HR consultants can review your handbook, provide recommended updates, and help communicate changes to your employees. We can customize a handbook tailored to your organization, ensuring that you and your employees are protected.

Read about how our employee handbook service helped a popular fast food franchise.

Request a free quote or fill out the brief form below for more information.